top of page
Search

Always-On Measurement Separates the Leaders: ANA Q3 2026 Benchmark Shows Performance Gap Widening to 23.6 Points

3 hours ago
7 min read

General Motors case shows cost, quality and outcomes improving together; new Chrome data adds a vendor-neutral read on ad clutter

The Association of National Advertisers (ANA) today released its Q3 2026 Programmatic Transparency Benchmark. The results show that the advertisers who measure cost and quality continuously, impression by impression, are the ones who keep their gains. Market-level TrueAdSpend was 43.1% in Q3, down from the record 45.1% in Q2 but still above every quarter of 2025.


Of every $1 million of programmatic spend in the Benchmark, $285,000 went to transaction costs and $284,000 to impressions that failed quality checks, leaving $431,000 in TrueAdSpend. The gap between higher- and lower-performing advertisers widened to 23.6 percentage points, the widest since the cohort series began in Q2 2025. This quarter's Benchmark also includes a General Motors case study and a first look at Google Chrome's new ad-clutter measurements.


The Benchmark defines a TrueImpression as an impression that is matched between DSP and verification logs, free of invalid traffic, measurable, and viewable to the MRC standard. The TrueAdSpend Index is the share of programmatic spend that reaches publishers for TrueImpressions, after transaction costs and spend on made-for-advertising (MFA) sites are deducted. TrueCPM is the effective cost of every thousand TrueImpressions. Read together with CPM, it shows where advertisers pay for impressions that fail quality requirements.


Quality Moves Every Quarter — and Headline CPM Cannot See It


Q3 shows why a quarterly snapshot is not enough. Two forces pulled TrueAdSpend down 2.0 points. Transaction costs rose for a third consecutive quarter, to 28.5%, taking 1.3 points more of every dollar. Loss of media productivity took 0.7 point more, as non-measurable spend climbed from 16.2% to 19.1%, driven by Connected TV, outweighing gains in viewability and MFA.


The CTV numbers show what headline CPM hides. CTV CPM rose only 2%, from $19.97 to $20.37. CTV TrueCPM rose almost 20%, from $26.97 to $32.26, as the share of CTV spend that could not be measured jumped from 16.9% to 24.0%. An advertiser watching CPM alone would have seen a stable quarter. An advertiser watching TrueCPM would have seen a fifth more cost for every quality impression.


The longer series tells the same story:

  • TrueAdSpend has risen from 36.0% in 2023 to 43.1% in Q3 2026, but not in a straight line: it fell to 36.3% in Q4 2025 before reaching its Q2 2026 record.

  • Transaction costs have climbed from 23.7% in Q4 2025 to 28.5% in Q3 2026, a 4.8-point rise in three quarters.

  • MFA fell from 1.3% to 0.4% of spend in Q3, and invalid traffic held at 0.1%. These gains hold only through continuous detection and filtering.


The Cohorts Show What Continuous Management Delivers


Each quarter, the marketers whose programmatic TrueAdSpend Index can be measured are ranked by that index and split into a higher and a lower half; each cohort figure is the simple average of its marketers’ own results. Higher-performing advertisers have kept TrueAdSpend between 52% and 57% in every quarter since Q2 2025, and reached 53.2% in Q3. Lower-performing advertisers have fallen in each of the last four quarters, from 41.4% in Q3 2025 to 29.6% in Q3 2026. The gap between them has grown from 14.0 points in Q2 2025 to 23.6 points today. In dollars, every $1 million of spend left the average higher-performing marketer $532,000 in TrueAdSpend, after $222,000 in transaction costs and $246,000 lost to quality issues. The average lower performer kept just $296,000, after $342,000 in transaction costs and $362,000 lost to quality issues.


Supply footprint does not explain the difference: the higher half ran on a wider supply set, 63,420 domains and apps against 37,653. Measurement and fees do. In Q3, lower performers lost 19.7% of spend to non-measurable inventory, against 13.4% for higher performers, and paid 34.2% of spend in transaction costs, against 22.2%. Only 29% of marketers exceeded 50% TrueAdSpend, down from 35% in Q2.


TrueCPM shows the same divide in price. The average lower-performing marketer paid a CPM of $6.75, against $9.12 for the average higher-performing marketer. After adjusting for quality, the gap narrowed to $1.06: TrueCPM was $12.34 for the average lower performer and $13.40 for the average higher performer. These are simple averages across the marketers in each half, not weighted by spend, so they do not compare directly with the market CPM ($6.41) and TrueCPM ($9.61).


General Motors: Lower Cost, Higher Quality and Better Outcomes at the Same Time


General Motors put the Benchmark's measures to work on its own Chevrolet programmatic buying. GM started from a strong base: 76.6% of its verification-matched spend, before fees, already bought TrueImpressions.


GM and Fiducia calculated TrueCPM for every domain and app on the existing inclusion list from April 1 to May 14. On May 15 they made one change: they curated the inclusion list on TrueCPM, keeping the domains and apps that were strong on both cost and quality. Comparing May 16 to July 3 with the period before:

  • TrueCPM fell 11%, and the CPM actually paid fell 9%.

  • Outcomes rose 30%, measured on GM's own site data, and average daily conversions rose 12%, with lower CPA.

  • The inclusion list shrank by 1,013 domains and apps, from 4,134 to 3,121, with no loss of pacing or delivery.


The pilot challenges the usual trade-off between price, quality and results. When the quality-adjusted cost of every domain, app and supply path is known, all three can improve together.


Google Chrome Data Adds a Vendor-Neutral Read on Ad Clutter


Since September 15, 2026, Google's Chrome browser has published experimental ad measurements for each website, based on real visits, including the share of the screen covered by ads. For the Q3 Benchmark, Fiducia matched these measurements to the top 2,000 web publishers by spend, covering 81% of Q3 web programmatic spend.


Ad clutter proved a strong signal of MFA sites. On the most cluttered sites, where ads cover 28% or more of the screen, 42% of the matched web spend went to sites on the Benchmark's MFA list, against 0.75% on the least cluttered sites (under 15%). These tier shares are measured on each tier's own matched web spend, a different basis from the 0.4% MFA share of total spend in the Cost Waterfall. Clutter shows almost no link to TrueCPM, the quality-adjusted price. That makes clutter a separate quality signal, not a price signal.


Advertisers differ widely. The median advertiser placed 3.9% of its matched web spend on heavy-clutter sites, where ads cover 20% or more of the screen, but the range ran from 0.4% to 18.4% across 19 advertisers. And 167 heavy-clutter sites, carrying $1.5 million of Q3 spend, are not on the MFA list: a review list that relies on no single vendor. Chrome's data covers web only (no CTV or apps), Chrome traffic only, and is still experimental.


“You cannot fix what you cannot see,” said Tim Brown, Co-founder and CEO, Fiducia. “The advertisers at the top of this Benchmark measure every impression against both price and quality, every day, and act on what they find. General Motors shows that this pays off in outcomes, not only in efficiency. Quality is not a premium you pay for. When you stop buying the waste, it is a saving you make, and CPM on its own is only a diagnostic.”


What's New This Quarter


  • The Performance Divide Widens: 53.2% TrueAdSpend for higher performers against 29.6% for lower performers — a 23.6-point gap, up from 21.2 points in Q2.

  • General Motors Case Study: TrueCPM down 11%, CPM down 9% and outcomes up 30% after curating Chevrolet's inclusion list on TrueCPM.

  • Chrome Ad-Clutter Data Added: 42% of matched web spend on the most cluttered sites goes to MFA-listed sites, against 0.75% on the least cluttered.

  • TrueAdSpend Eases From Its Record: 43.1% in Q3 ($431,000 of every $1 million), from 45.1% in Q2, still above every 2025 quarter.

  • Transaction Costs Rise Again: 28.5% of spend (+1.3 points), the third quarterly increase in a row.

  • TrueCPM Index Widens Slightly: 33.3% at market level (+0.7 point), as TrueCPM ($9.61) rose faster than CPM ($6.41).

  • Participation Keeps Growing: 102 marketers contributed data, up 20%, across $175.5 million of spend and 23.1 billion impressions.


Turning Transparency into Results


The Q3 findings show that quality gains only last when they are measured and managed continuously. Advertisers can protect their gains by tracking TrueCPM alongside CPM continuously rather than quarterly, curating inclusion lists on quality-adjusted cost, checking their spend on heavily cluttered sites, setting measurement requirements for CTV sellers and platforms, and requesting an itemized breakdown of every fee line.


Developed in partnership with TAG TrustNet and Fiducia, the ANA Programmatic Transparency Benchmark provides quarterly, impression-level insights into programmatic media cost, quality, and performance. Built on log-level data from leading advertisers and platforms, the Benchmark helps marketers identify waste, improve media quality, and strengthen outcomes across web, mobile, and CTV environments.


Access the Q3 2026 report here: Q3 2026 Benchmark Access


For more information about participating in the ANA Programmatic Transparency Benchmark, visit www.fiducia.eco/benchmark or contact programmatic@ana.net.


ABOUT THE ANA

The Association of National Advertisers (ANA) is the definitive voice of the marketing industry. Since 1910, the ANA has set and advanced the agenda for marketing transformation, connecting more than 1,600 member companies to an influential global network of insights and resources that drive growth. ANA members represent 20,000 brands and $400 billion in annual marketing investment. Through industry-leading research, the CMO Growth Council, and the ANA Growth Agenda, the ANA empowers marketers to shape the future of marketing and create lasting impact for their organizations and the industry.


ABOUT TAG TRUSTNET

Launched by the Trustworthy Accountability Group (TAG) in partnership with technology provider Fiducia, TAG TrustNet is a cross-industry initiative establishing standardized transparency requirements for programmatic advertising supply chain participants, in alignment with the TAG Certified for Transparency program. Powered by Fiducia's technology, TAG TrustNet enables the collection and reconciliation of impression-level log data across suppliers, improving transparency, accountability, and efficiency in programmatic advertising.


ABOUT FIDUCIA

Fiducia is an independent programmatic media intelligence and optimization company helping advertisers improve media quality, cost efficiency, and business outcomes. As the technology and analytics partner behind the ANA Programmatic Transparency Benchmark, Fiducia combines industry-wide benchmarking, the TrueCPM measurement framework, and supply chain intelligence to help advertisers reduce waste, optimize media investments, and drive better business outcomes.

 

 
 
 

Comments


New Logo Fiducia with text (white 1).png
Innovate UK logo
Get in touch
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2026 by Fiducia DLT Limited

bottom of page